About Me

My photo
I am a Baha'i talking about everyday things and events from my personal Baha'i perspective. Went to York University in 1986, I've been a Baha'i since 1987, got married to Fiona Saunders-Priem in 1988, we have two children and I have had a pretty full and eventful life ! Thoroughly enjoying it and nothing to complain about. Contact paulsaunderspriem@gmail.com

Thursday, 19 November 2026

Identity claims and why we have to provide evidence for them!

 Every identity claim like "I am a atheist" or "I am an agnostic", relies on an implicit definition of God . No atheist/agnostic can make those identity claims without a God definition in their heads. Providing that definition  explicitly  to prove  real world  atheist / agnostic identity is a necessary    burden of proof required for those identity  labels to make sense or else they are incoherent and nonsensical  . All those of atheist or agnostic beliefs have  a burden of proof  before anyone, including themselves ,  can meaningfully evaluate their beliefs for  or against their "I am" identity claim. They must first define what they are claiming non-belief in or are rejecting . They have to define  what they mean by God because they are making a positive real world identity belief claim. That requires a burden of proof.
There's   a three part  burden of proof for an "I am" statement.   Claiming a non-religious identity   carries three  responsibilities,   1) the conceptual definition  about  what God means to them (definition , clarity ,burden of proof ),  2) an  internal state of mind belief (  do they believe what they say  ) and  3) performative proof e.g. (atheist/agnostics  not  having  anything to do with religion in their actions) 
Without that first step defining the term God ,saying "I am an atheist "   is like saying  "I am a fan" without naming the sport or the team. The atheist/agnostic believers  making the identity claim   need  to say explicitly the  God definition  they are using  so others can judge whether the atheist or agnostic identity is true  with regard to what they are claiming .
Therefore saying, "I am an atheist" or "I am an agnostic", carries a burden of proof  to prove the authenticity (real world objective reality) of the person's identity belief. So meet the burden of proof please atheists and agnostics. If you don't you are not atheists or agnostics as  you're making  empty claims . (Paul Saunders-Priem, member of the Baha'i Faith)

No comments:

Post a Comment